Ep 01TBB小小观察员来也～第一集首先持观望态度，毕竟在演员阵容基本玩不出花样的今天，能有此题材也能证明监制林志华以及编审关皓月不落俗套、力争上游的决心；首集节奏不错，没有太多累赘，不算复杂的人物关系也很一目了然。监狱题材玩得最好的当然是美剧，［监狱风云］、［女子监狱］之类，港式监狱剧因其尺度限制在以及受众(师奶)限制，必定会对监狱里的黑暗、疯狂元素有所柔化，比起美国监狱里动不动就QJ、暴打致死等重口情节，港式监狱剧里也会有，但只是浮光掠影式的展现。而监狱题材最容易落俗的是对狱中人员过度的同情与煽情，而对案件背后的社会动因避而不谈。［再战］一剧聪明地将重点放在讲述惩教人员与狱中人员共同发生的故事上，借此表达“守望互助”的大和谐主题，虽然和谐是和谐，但不失为另一个角度。这一集值得点赞的是后半段采用掠影的形式对狱中群体的身份、所犯罪行等进行逐一盘点，很凝重，有电影感。其实群像戏一直是港剧弱项，很多剧中的群像戏既无重点人物，也没有形成此起彼伏的剧力。且看这一部如何。目前看来第一集重点讲述的杨潮凯(抱歉忘了角色名)、以及凶残的叶细响、“读书仔”等角色都埋下了不错的伏笔。惟一担心的就是20集的体量实在太捉襟见肘，光是主角感情线就有三对(吴启华&徐子珊；王浩信&何超仪；黄德斌&梁铮/朱千雪)，还能不能分出戏份给狱中众人完善故事线索，的确存疑。至于主角，Z3其实连着几部戏演技都有大跃进，“大叔控专业户”的她此次又搭配大叔吴启华，虽然是闭着眼睛都能想到的“死板固执大叔VS俏皮新人类萌萝莉”的设定，但奇怪的是还蛮有CP感啊；Man Sir和Q Sir之间的不同工作风格冲突也蛮有意思，且看接下来继续深入展现；另外还未出现的何超仪绝逼是视后姿态，值得期待；“福雅”梁铮，我知道很多人喜欢她很久了，看柔情似水、端庄典雅的她和硬汉黄德斌如何碰撞出感觉；另外再说一句：为什么有吴启华的地方总有朱千雪？？？采用倒叙虽然并不新鲜，可是也算是给剧集增添了一些悬疑气息，叶细响到底有没有撂低Man sir(当然不可能撂低，港剧那么和谐)，一年中Man Sir到底和他发生了哪些恩恩怨怨，算是支持继续追剧的一个动力。继续Follow中，此帖日日更。EP 02继续深入的第二集，黄德斌饰演的翁Sir和朱千雪饰演的迟姑娘所代表的更生事务组的事务与Man Sir他们所在的惩教组的事务有机地结合了起来，可以看出剧集想要表达的主题是：现在“监狱”名称的修改(改成“惩教所”)意味着监狱不再是一个简单粗暴关押囚犯的地方，而是一个从收押到教化甚至关注他们出狱后的生活状态，这样一个完整的、有机的过程。片尾Man Sir讲的蜗牛的故事真的太动人。嘉嘉的No Fear熊真的让人想起了［冲上云霄］中的Triangle娃娃。一个小小的物件可以带给人那么大的力量，你别说荒谬，你别不信。最让人感动的是Man Sir问嘉嘉为什么突然不嫁人了，嘉嘉扑闪着漂亮无辜的大眼睛说，因为我不想像那些犯人一样，做一些会让自己后悔一辈子的事。很俗气的对白，但却真实可感。因为我看到奇景都没想起他，所以我不想嫁给他。嘉嘉，点赞！------------------------------------------------------------------华丽丽的分割线拖延症楼主终于来更贴了~~~从刚看完的Ep 09倒回去吧Ep 0920集小容量但却故事线索纷繁复杂的剧集必定会每集信息量都很大。这集尤其。开头十分钟就抛出了一句“我也想试一颗永世难忘的鱼蛋！”振聋发聩。饰演文上游的心颖BB据称是HK新一代女神，其实还行，长得邻家，演技不让人讨厌，但称不上很好，整体比陈凯琳、蔡思贝之类的好不少。（个人意见，请勿拍砖~~~）梁铮，多少人爱她的福雅，以及和古仔的CP。她还是很美，很有气质，Ally这个角色前面一直不讨喜，但直到这一集才真正刷出了深度、刷出了好感。她说的那句“其实我都做过监等。那时真的很傻， 爱一个人爱到不分对与错，竟然做一些违法的事希望引起她注意。”那样心酸又洗尽铅华的笑，让我莫名想起康华。而与翁Sir海边谈心一段戏，最后她冲他俏皮一笑，说，其实我不介意你对我有没有感情的，或许我们从朋友做起呀，你能不能做我朋友呢？这样温柔明朗的笑容，相信没人能拒绝。这一集高潮在丁好好上庭自述一段。何超仪的演技自不必赘言，就只是很平淡的几句台词却句句有深意，十分贴合人物市井、粗鄙但却真心实意的性格。“我这辈子最重要就是我的儿子和我的腿，平时我都可以跟人好来好去，我不爱惹是生非，但是谁要敢碰我的儿子和我的腿，我那个暴戾的性格又会冒出来，我真的会跟你”死过“的！所以，你们可不可以不要动我的儿子我的腿。”那种近乎哀求的无奈是那么真实，说的都是大白话，没有拐来拐去的，却让人心酸。“我来这里(监狱)以后，这里的姑娘告诉我，暴力是解决不了问题的，要冷静，要有同理心，我才知道原来做人是要学懂控制自己的。”是的，对于一个没有上过几天学，更没有一对以身作则的父母教导的人来说，学坏真的只是分分钟的事，但“我本善良”，不管做错多少，只要肯回头，总有明天。“我的心是空的，我的儿子可以填补我的心。”想起丁好好刚出现的时候，还在监狱里的婴儿房，几位妈妈在逗乐各自的小孩，一派安静祥和的样子。但转瞬间妈妈们就开始掐起来，让观众错愕：原来我们忘了这是在监狱，这些妈妈只有母性大发时稍微消停一点，在她们入狱前，也非什么善男信女。可母爱是人世间最伟大的感情，可以消融一切矛盾，就像惩教人员再三问丁好好真的不上诉吗，华女和她的女儿老是欺负你和你的儿子恒恒，丁好好朴实一笑，“不上诉了，她也是个妈妈，我理解她的心情。要是我把事情闹大了，她就不能在这个婴儿房了，就必须要跟她的女儿分开，我怎么忍心做这种事。”这，便是她刚刚所说的“同理心”吧，己所不欲勿施于人，“在这里(监狱)做妈妈的，有哪个不觉得自己对不起小孩呢？”为了孩子，她发誓在监狱里再也不搞事，一定要忍，因为可以获得减刑，这样就可以在孩子满三岁必须要离开婴儿房的时候可以跟孩子一起放出去。最后一段，三百只No Fear熊，也太催泪了吧！前面是“见到双彩虹你会想起谁”，后面是“现在还有两百九十八只，你还可以不见(遗失)No Fear熊两百九十八次”，这样的桥段，太“港剧”，太烂俗，可我们每次都受落，因心里永远有一颗温暖到软塌塌的心。而硕仔，真真切切感受到他那种万念俱灰、世界一下子黑了的感觉，在监狱里二十年循规蹈矩、从来不犯事就只为了一个希望、一个支撑，而人没有了支撑，真的不知该如何继续走下去。片尾曲“谁要你分开，谁没将来 隔膜铁壁 也隔不到爱……”适时响起 伴随着邓颂恩与妹妹可儿终于相见、无语泪千行 真的 我的泪也止不住了……【一天一更，今天就到这里】Ep 10 与 Ep 11这两集 就记经典对白可以了嘉：杀人鲸一走开，平日在她身边的人就会取代她，你觉得杀人鲸、乌鹰她们，在这里如此嚣张，出去后又会怎样？好：“行先死先”(身先士卒)個只咯。嘉：其实她们真傻，这里是监狱，又不是真实的社会，在这里她们还能欺骗自己，但出去后还能这样生活吗？在这里把香烟当钱花，但出去后香烟不能买食物，交不到租，更不能帮儿子交学费。在狱中每个囚犯都受到我们的监管，受到我们的保护，而我们的责任是帮你学好悔过，学好正确的价值观，但出去后就要靠你自己努力，面对真实的生活。傻珠以为给杀人鲸香烟，她就会喜欢她，跟她交朋友，傻珠的理解能力比较低，但你不是。杀人鲸这种人，基本上做的一切都是错的，如果任由她这样，她只会变本加厉，最终受害者还不是你自己？其实你快出狱了，不该避开所有人，而是该学会分辨是非，控制自己的情绪，最重要的是因为你有个儿子，小朋友是无知的，你做什么他都会跟着你做，就算你用暴力解决问题，他都觉得你做得对。好：我是粗人，不善辞令，但我知道要不是你，我肯定被加监，杀人鲸是卑鄙，但我左算右算还是赢不了她，所以我才纵容她。其实我不是不知道何谓正义，不过我自身难保，还说什么正义？嘉：其实只要你内心善良就是正义。最重要是你心里有条底线，知道什么是对，什么是错，你的内心方向是正确的话，将来走的路就正确，你儿子也一样。我希望你在这里懂得守规矩，出去后懂得守法，我真不想看到你回来。好：我答应你！不好意思姚姑娘，之前我……我乱说话，我说你打份工不知为了什么，我现在明白了，你打份工救了我，还救了我儿子。--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------第十集嘉嘉的职业属性终于真正上线，从那个懵懂无知的小女孩慢慢了解工作对于自己的意义。说起来Q记活得好累呀，又要搭救丁好好，又要关心桂哥，还要做嘉嘉的心理医生……彷徨的嘉嘉说想避开Man Sir所以不做惩教了，Q记说得真好，“你不做惩教，是因为你想避开Uncle Man，还是因为做惩教对于你来说已经完全没有意义？”对的，人最重要是要明白自己干一件事是为什么，周遭的确会有很多杂音，肯定不都尽如人意，但只有内心坚定，才能抵制住外界的压力。而心颖BB演的文上游，虽然演技的确稚嫩，但好在脸看着还算邻家，末尾一段，虽然又有烂俗的雨中操练苦情戏码，但是Man Sir说的那句“我以为一直都是我照顾你，谁知原来是你一直在照顾我的感受。”也蛮感人。。。这两集简直是洗脑集，Q记说的“笨可以学，学就代表有勇气，发抖代表懦弱，懦弱怎会有勇气？”，文上游说的，“当你做一件很喜欢的事，但得不到至亲的支持，真是挺难熬的。”都是很普通但很接地气的对白，让人很有共鸣。而嘉嘉同丁好好说的那句“内心善良就是正义”真的很俗烂，但你别说，很多时候就是这么简单的一句话，可救人于浮屠。11集嘉嘉同Uncle Man简直不要太甜！！！嘉嘉那种小女孩的黏人和多情表现得淋漓尽致，而吴启华的大叔魅力完全不用演！！！将那种欲拒还迎、无奈和犹疑演得真是入木三分……本来叔侄恋就是容易刷好感的呢，感觉吴启华帅回了程志美的高度。11集有一处细节，很感人，又心酸，刚出狱的丁好好来接恒仔，可是恒仔却不认识她了……丁好好无奈地笑着说，可能因为他一出世就看我穿囚服，现在穿别的衣服他不认识了。看似简单的一句话，却说出多少无奈。Ep 12这一集最让人动容的是桂哥。说起来张国强这几年在TVB总是要演一些非常平面、单薄的奸角，完全过场角色，鼠目寸光之流。这一次看前面以为也是一个见钱眼开、心胸狭窄的碌碌无为之辈，但这一集中惩教众学员捡到他的笔记，上面记载的全是桂哥几十年来“教仔”心得，直到现在惩教署遍地都是他的“仔”(学生)，他却一只脚踏进了监狱。想来也是感慨。直到这里才觉得桂哥这个角色十分有血有肉，而且剧集直到现在也很好地保持了“万事皆有因果”这个逻辑，剧中没有绝对的好人或坏人，每个人做事都有其原因并且剧集毫无偏私地都一一展现，即使是桂哥，他也是因为年轻时忙于工作、疏忽家人，才会导致家中巨变、背上巨额债务，而桂哥也只是单纯想要帮轻家里，才一时行差踏错……Man Sir生日会上替桂哥带给一班手足的话说得真好：我们的工作真的很重要，但家人也一样重要，不要因为工作而忽略家人，毕竟是因为有他们在身后back up，我们才能无后顾之忧地去做自己的事。令人想起常常见诸报端的一些新闻，说的是某些人为了“救社会”而家人都不要了，家中老父都病重了仍然坚守岗位不回家，我觉得，这种灭人伦的价值观，不值得提倡。毕竟，有家才有国，顺序不能乱。同期［老表2］中郭晋安饰演的环保分子林在野不也是在外漂泊二十多年，回到家后才幡然醒悟，他妈问他：儿子，你不拯救地球了吗，他说：我还要继续拯救地球，但是地球不是只有我一个人在拯救，可你们只有我。对嘛。这才是正的三观啊。而某个惩教人员说的“不知从什么时候开始，我们上班只懂得抱怨什么时候换班，而全然忘记了这份工作的意义”也让人感触良多。每一份工作，就算干之前有多么喜欢，它始终都会折损你对它的爱。而明白自己为什么干一份工作，确定那份意义，的确很重要。很感激剪辑人员没有把桂哥这一长段删减，毕竟这一段看起来比较枯燥，不如剧情冲突激烈的那么“抓人”。但一边播着桂哥的旁白，画面是他锒铛入狱的一系列过程，量身高、按手模等等，的确触目惊心、效果很好。尤其记得桂哥对当时的“新仔”Fred说，你不要看得人那么紧，（因为他连囚犯上厕所都盯得很紧）虽然人家是犯了事进来，但你都要给人家一点尊严……这段，真的很有人情味。另一段，Man Sir生日趴，Q记同光仔在阳台谈心，光仔因为看到翁Sir和Ally走得很近，心里郁闷，说了句：“中意一个人，是无关他帅不帅（对，黄德斌的确不帅，但真的很charm!）”，Q记说“对，也无关她的背景，以及出身”，二人各有心事，光仔说的是翁Sir，而Q记说的是丁好好。这一段，也很“抓人”。-------------------------------------------------------2014.11.01一大早爬起来看大结局 发现又是好多集没更了 最近是太忙了 现在去逛街 晚点回来更！

【铁拳英雄】我曾经也是喜欢过陈展鹏的，还管人家叫展鹏哥哥，现在只能叫在我心中过气的展鹏哥哥，可人家依然能演男一演主角，在TVB也是一线，薪水依然可以傲视群雄，可是他的演技真的一成不变，真的没变化，这就叫演员之间的区别，也可以叫差距吧，王浩信、谭俊彦、张振朗的努力，不是喊喊口号，而是真的看到他们在一点一点的变化，你所有的努力都不会白费的。

这部剧还是很好看的，至少只能在TVB还能看到认认真真在打的剧，不是咔咔开枪，不是唰唰做点五毛特效，演员都实实在在的去打功夫拼拳脚，视觉上好看很多，女演员很拼，但是我真的不喜欢皮衣，真心觉得没有创意，有模仿之嫌。

剧本整体还算扎实，反正剧情推动到哪里都还算比较扣人心弦，我内心还是很期待这种题材的，因为少见了。

我不满足的地方，是我特别喜欢元秋，希望她的戏份能多点。

推荐看，下一部见#我的第191个剧评

Feel Good is a low budget 6-episode TV show which mysteriously skipped my attention when it was first brought up by a friend: probably because it features no big star (Lisa is one, but in a small role), and British TV shows like Fleabag and Killing Eve have raised the bar very high now.

However, one night, I started to watch the first episode and was very impressed. The not so sub plot of addiction is so well-written. I really like it when Mae (its main character shares the same name with the writer and lead actor, which is a bit confusing) expands the definition of ‘addiction’: ‘it’s all the same feelings, craving, and withdrawl, and relief, and obsession. We are just swapping one addiction for another’. By doing that, Mae Martin (I will use the full name when referring to the creator) connects the love story and Mae’s struggle to stay clean together. Mae Martin challenges the audience to view addiction as not only a struggle among a group of people, but something many of us face when being in a toxic relationship with partners, or, say, social media. By then, I am convinced Feel Good is quite good because the creators know ‘nuances’. Its focus on addiction also reminds me of Killing Eve S2, the key word for its 2nd season is ‘obsession’. While both handle compulsive/toxic feelings between people/people and object, Killing Eve’s take on obsession is disappointing, Feel Good, on the other hand, only gets better episode by episode.

Story aside, I am mesmerized by how the show introduces the love story to the audience. It is fast-paced. As Guardian remarks, ‘Feel Good moves so quickly and lightly that it seems impossible it could also be managing to construct characters and burrow into psyches as deeply and empathically as it does.’ You never need to fast-forward; it’s densely-packed but you won’t feel stressful; the plots mingle effortlessly. It takes 30 seconds for Mae and George to fall in love with each other. I love how unconventional and unapologetic it is. I love how an LGBTQIA (bless Joyce) story focus on how the two lovers enjoy their relationship (at least for the most part) without giving too much attention to how they are unsure if the other is into them, or suffering from loneliness because they can’t find a partner. Of course the loneliness issue exists and there is suffering, but there are many representations of those already. Feel Good shows how the relationship can be the start, rather than the ending, of a story.

I also like how the struggles of Mae and George are more about themselves making choices than them being in disagreement with a suffocating society. It is refreshing to see not only Mae’s parents, but George’s mother, support their sexuality. Mae’s gig pals don’t make a fuss about her having a girlfriend. The roommate Phil is an angel. The lead of the support group is a gay man; Lava is loved by her mother regardless of her sexuality. While Binky’s husband and his friends are ‘piece of shit’, I don’t see them as homophobic (I could be wrong though). The show demonstrates that everyone can and should be nice to LGBT+ community. I like how Feel Good doesn’t use societal approval as a trope; instead, it allows us to see Mae and George as individuals who make their own decisions. Yes, sexuality is and will be important in their lives, but they don’t let it to devour them, they can still breathe.

The relationship is beautifully written and wonderfully performed. I mean THE CHEMISTRY!! Yes there is sex. As Mae Martin said, she didn’t want the lesbian sex to be voyeuristic. I congratulate her in doing a fantastic job!! Feel Good has amazing sex scenes: they are romantic, witty, hilarious, and honest. The director and writers make sure the sex scenes are not about sex/lust only, they are also about female pleasure. Mae and George communicate and share their sexual preferences; they don’t force their fetish on the other, instead, they ask politely. The show doesn’t mystify lesbian sex: even lesbians can’t cum and that’s ok! Feel Good has achieved what Sex Education has done: it has educated people (older than high schoolers) how to have sex, and more importantly, how to discern when the relationship is going south.

There are nudity scenes and they are (quite literally) serving the plot: it is when Mae feels most vulnerable physically. The paradox of the physicality and the personality is, however, not restricted to gay people. Mae is struggling because she believes however hard she tries, she can never have George in the long haul because George is ‘culturally straight’. George, however, insists this idea is just in Mae’s head. (Or is it?) It becomes apparent that the couple is not on the same page on many things. Mae is shy but she wants public validation of their relationship: she wants to be blessed by George’s family and friends. George is popular (win the lottery) but she is ultra private when it comes to Mae. She points out her friends just want to crack a joke and emotions (mind, not sexuality), for them, is gross. Eventually, George will have to face her own real emotions. There is a moment where Mae questions why George never like/retweet her social media stuffs. As Fleabag says ‘Hair is everything’, the (non)usage of social media, I argue, is (almost) everything. This again shows the discrepancy between the couple – which, of course, is normal; in every relationship/friendship, such disagreements happen and that’s what makes this show so relatable.

It is interesting to note that the dynamic between the two flows all the time. I find myself on the side of Mae and then I am on George’s side! For example, the first episode shows Mae concealing her addiction history from George, which is a bit dishonest; but George also makes Mae think she’s already mentioned her to her friends while actually she’s dating some Crenshaw dude. I find it especially interesting that while George is portrayed as a cold person (she leaves Mae alone in a party; she’s rather cold towards Phil etc etc), Mae can also be quite aloof – check what she does to Lava. When she says let’s not share this with Maggie, it is as if George were saying let’s not tell my friends now.

Talking about George and her friends, I really like how the show does about their friendship. It shows that those friendships, even though ‘long haul’, are not necessarily genuine. Indeed, things can be tricky, if not scary, when friends finally choose to be honest with each other, right?

Binky’s husband and friends are hilarious characters, but the show makes sure not all the male characters are caricatured. I like Phil a lot; he’s giving me the neighbor who ended up marrying Hannah’s boyfriend’s sister in Girls, especially when he’s mentioning all the baby stuffs. Mae’s dad is a charming character; but I am not sure if he’s a good dad. His ‘Oh I need to check the garden’ is a specimen of dad type, who leaves all the dirty job of communicating with kids to mums. The show also inserts in a MeToo story plot where things turn sour quickly. In all, the portrayals of male characters are multifaceted. Well done.

Last but not the least: small roles. Does the show even have small roles? Because everyone shines. Even the shop assistant of that sex shop: the scene is so funny and captivating. Lisa Kudrow is funny but in a cold way – which is really nice. I am not crazy about her first appearance in the laptop; seeing her appear in Blackpool is a real surprise for me (and Mae). I love the scene in Ghost Train the most. Arguing in a horror house/moving train, with all the noise and terrifying man-makes while discussing ‘real emotions’, which is the most terrifying of all – what a genius idea!! The fact that the show keeps vague about why Mae is cast out of the family is an interesting one; I quite like how her mother points out her privilege and that she has everything she wants when she grows up. Again, the show is looking at the mysterious and intricate human mind that is not so easily explainable. Apart from that, I don’t think there are a lot of TV shows that discuss ‘privilege’. Kudos to the writers for highlighting this aspect.

The photography is really pretty. It, like TEOTFW, has a consistent tone, which is even reflected when Mae and George are in bed. Note the beautiful blue shadow. The music is nice. The costume looks comfy and lovely (never let the costume steal the show– I’m talking to you, Killing Eve). My favorite, as I said earlier is the pace of narration. Mae has run a lot and it is a signature of Feel Good, like Fleabag’s looking at the camera.

Feel Good is about a female stand-up comedian. In the States, there is The Marvelous Mrs Maisel. Both Mae and Midge suffer from a backfire from they using real-life stories with their partner (judging from S1 finale, haven’t watched S2 yet). It is interesting to think how personal the stand-up mateials can be, but having just watched Hannah Gadsby’s Nanette, I am reminding myself that in order to make things funny, the ‘truth’ can be compromised. While Nanette is almost metafictional when Hannah approaches/disconstructs what makes comedy, I don’t think that is the angle Feel Good is heading towards. However, it is still fit to think about the show amongst the powerful works by Mae Martin’s fellow female comedians. The freshness of the show also reminds me of Girls (with its minute depictions of modern female life) and Fleabag (with its candidacy about real emotions). Feel Good deserves more recognition and PLEASE CAN WE HAVE SEASON 2 THANK YOU NETFLIX!!

看了20分钟，简直了，浪费钱做这种东西简直浪费资源浪费生命。

完全不说人话，拍给孩子看的？说什么生儿育女，生生死死，还奈何桥，断头的人，这他么都是什么东西。

小二货，娘们，这些台词也是该给孩子看的吗？

浪费了这个3D效果。

画风简直恐怖片，王母娘娘是腹黑大BOSS，废话连篇，为了筹时间，一句话分成2遍讲。

在最后一集中，Pablo在死前看到了亡灵，他的表哥古斯塔夫。他们平静的坐在广场上聊天，没有任何人来打扰。

就好像国内民间传说的一样，人在离世之前会有自己已经离世的的亲人回到这个世界来接他。

这样的安排让人叹服编剧的安排。 也让人不由自主的遐想万分。无论是平凡的无名之辈，或是十恶不赦、恶贯满盈的强盗，还是在自己的领域里有杰出贡献的天才，到头来都是一样，不分信仰和国籍。